Kamil Bernaerts

Doctor in Political Science

Polarisation versus democracy?

On the fine line between the conflict democracies need and the conflict that harms them.

I am a doctor in Political Science, studying social conflict and polarisation within democratic societies. I specifically want to identify the fine line between harmful conflict and democracy.

To do so, I devoted my PhD dissertation to the question whether polarisation undermines democracy. It was published as a book by VUBPRESS in 2025. I am continuing my academic career as a postdoctoral researcher at VUB, working on the broader question of conflict and democracy.

I also teach an introductory course on political science at UHasselt, and regularly give public lectures on my research.

Dr. Kamil Bernaerts
Kamil Bernaerts. Photo: Greetje Van Buggenhout

Recent publications

Polarising alone? The relationship between social contact and affective polarisation in Belgium and the UK

Bernaerts, K. & Junius, N.

Abstract

How does everyday social contact shape affective polarisation? Drawing on original survey data in Belgium and the United Kingdom (N = 2.000), we explore how different degrees and kinds of social contact relate to affective polarisation. While some consider social contact as a driver of polarisation others consider it to be a remedy. Our results provide evidence for the former argument: individuals who are less lonely, more engaged in their communities, and more socially connected tend to be more affectively polarised. However, our results also suggest that the kind of social contact matters. In the UK, we find that bridging ties - contact with people of a different background - are associated with lower levels of affective polarisation once the overall degree of social contact is controlled for. Nevertheless, the general finding remains: polarisation is higher among those with more frequent social contacts, irrespective of the nature of those connections. This indicates that the degree and kind of social contact have an independent, additive effect on affective polarisation. They do not condition one another but rather operate through different social mechanisms.

Hate, not dislike? Understanding anti-democratic attitudes through a multi-dimensional understanding of affective polarization

Bernaerts, K.

Abstract

Rising affective polarization (AP) in Western democracies raises concerns about anti-democratic attitudes like political intolerance and support for violence. As prior findings in the field have yielded contrasting results, this paper argues that a more nuanced understanding of AP is needed to better understand this relationship. It does so by examining horizontal AP—polarization toward ordinary citizens rather than toward political parties—anchored in pro- and anti-woke positions, using original survey data from Belgium and the UK (N = 2,000). Within this horizontal form of AP, three distinct measures are then compared: dislike, social distance, and negative emotions (hate, anger and frustration). First, it examines the association between dislike and social distance and anti-democratic attitudes. Second, it includes negative emotions as a potential mediator. Key findings reveal that political intolerance is mostly driven by social distance (and less so by dislike), while its relation with support for violence runs almost entirely through negative emotions. These results suggest anti-democratic attitudes stem more from avoiding and hating opponents rather than simply disliking them, indicating that emotional intensity matters more than basic negative sentiment.

Fight or unite? Exploring the link between consensus institutions, polarization and political violence in 113 democracies over time (1900–2023)

Bernaerts, K. & Caluwaerts, D.

Abstract

Political violence poses an alarming threat to contemporary democracies and is often attributed to rising polarization. This paper investigates how democratic institutions moderate the relationship between identity-based polarization and violence, hypothesizing that this relationship depends upon a country’s institutional structure. Studying 113 democracies over time (1900−2023), we find that while identity-based polarization is associated with political violence, democracies with a federal structure and a rigid constitution show a significantly weaker relationship between polarization and violence. These results offer a rare positive perspective within polarization studies, showing that violence – polarization’s worst threat to democratic peaceful coexistence – is related to the institutional organization of conflict in society.

Institutional design and polarization. Do consensus democracies fare better in fighting polarization than majoritarian democracies?

Bernaerts, K., Blanckaert, B.; Caluwaerts, D.

Abstract

It is often claimed that we are living in an age of increasing polarization. Political views, opinions, and worldviews become increasingly irreconcilable (idea-based polarization), while at the same time society appears to be getting fractured in antagonistic, opposing camps (identity-based polarization). However, a closer look at international datasets reveals that these forms of polarization do not affect all democracies to the same extent. Levels of identity-based and idea-based polarization strongly vary across countries. The question then becomes what can explain these diverging levels of polarization. In this paper, we hypothesize that the institutional design of a country impacts polarization, and that consensus democracies would display lower levels of polarization. Based on a quantitative analysis of the Comparative Political Dataset and Varieties of Democracy data in 36 countries over time (2000–2019), our results show that institutions did matter to a great extent, and in the hypothesized direction. Countries with consensus institutions, and more in particular PR electoral systems, multiparty coalitions, and federalism did exhibit lower levels of both issue-based and identity-based polarization, thereby confirming our expectations. Moreover, we found that consensus democracies tend to be better at coping with identity-based polarization, while the effect on idea-based polarization is smaller.

All publications →

Awards

2024 · Democratization

Frank Cass Prize

Best article of 2023, for our study of polarisation in consensus and majoritarian democracies. About the prize ↗

2021 · EUTOPIA university alliance

EUTOPIA Co-tutelle PhD Scholarship

Funding for a joint PhD at Vrije Universiteit Brussel and the University of Warwick.

2021 · Vrije Universiteit Brussel

Excellence Award

Top student in the master's programme, Faculty of Economy and Social Sciences. Full CV →

Public speaking

As a publicly funded researcher, I give public lectures when I am invited to events on polarisation, democracy and critical thinking. This includes the PACT school tour, a VUB initiative through which I give guest lectures for secondary school students.

As a senior academic fellow at the Hannah Arendt Institute, I help organise academic and public events and bring expertise and insights to the Institute.

Lectures, workshops and media →
Kamil Bernaerts giving a public lecture
Photo: Greetje Van Buggenhout